Catch
Your neighborhood fish counter since 2011.
Feb 23, 2026
Today's Catch
What came in this morning — sourced from boats we know by name, priced on the board, sold until it's gone.
Whole Branzino
Soft-Shell Crab
Watch Hill Oysters
Pacific Halibut
Wild Striped Bass
Littleneck Clams
Order Ahead
Ready when you arrive.
Nothing sits under a heat lamp here.
Pick-up same day · No payment upfront
For Entertaining
Platters & Trays
Assembled at the counter the morning of your event. Order 24 hours ahead and we'll have it waiting — wrapped, iced, and ready to impress.
The Friday Night Tower
Oysters, littlenecks, jumbo shrimp, half lobster, crab claws — all on crushed ice with mignonette and cocktail sauce.
Shucked-to-Order Dozen
Your choice of Watch Hill, Blue Point, or Pemaquid — opened at the counter, served with lemon and our house mignonette.
Entertaining Platter
Whole roasted fish, smoked salmon, pickled herring, house-made rillettes, crackers, and seasonal garnish. Chef-assembled.
The Neighborhood
Who Shops Here
The counter is a gathering place. Here are a few of the people who make it what it is.
The 7 a.m. crowd
Every Tuesday, a small group of home cooks shows up before the cases are fully set. They've been coming since we opened. They don't need the chalkboard — they just ask Marco what's good.
Chef Priya Nair picks up halibut at 6 a.m.
"I've been coming to Catch for three years. I text ahead for whatever's coming off the boat. They always hold the best pieces for me. My guests at the estate never know why the fish tastes different — I do."
Saturday Oyster Bar — next pop-up: Mar 1
Every first Saturday of the month, we set up the raw bar outside. Watch Hill oysters, house mignonette, cold Muscadet. Noon until we run out. No ticket, no reservation — just show up.
Same-Morning Alerts
Join the Catch List
When rare fish land — black sea bass, live scallops, wild salmon — you hear first. One text, no spam, unsubscribe anytime. Just your phone number.
340+
Neighbors on the list
6 am
When the texts go out
0
Spam messages sent
Order Ahead
Reserve Your Order
We'll have it ready on ice when you arrive.
From the counter — Feb 23
"Two boats came in this morning — beautiful whole branzino from Montauk and a surprise haul of soft-shell crabs. Oysters from Watch Hill are shucking perfectly. — Marco"